A Massachusetts wrongful death resource · Danvers, MA · Serving families since 1994 Speak with an attorney: 617-415-2100

Wrongful Death of an Unborn Child or Stillbirth in Massachusetts

A pregnant woman is rear-ended on Route 1 at thirty-four weeks and loses the baby. A delivery is mismanaged and the child is stillborn. A mother at twelve weeks is struck by a drunk driver and miscarries. Each family has suffered a death, and each asks whether Massachusetts law recognizes it. The answer depends on a line the Supreme Judicial Court drew fifty years ago and has maintained since: whether the child was viable. This page explains the rule, the claims that exist on each side of the line, how the cases are proved, and what the mother’s own claim adds.

The viability rule

In Mone v. Greyhound Lines, Inc., 368 Mass. 354 (1975), the Supreme Judicial Court held that a viable fetus is a “person” within the meaning of the Massachusetts wrongful death statute, and that the personal representative of a stillborn viable child may bring a wrongful death action for the child’s death caused by negligence. The decision brought Massachusetts in line with the majority of states and established that the wrongful death statute protects a child capable of living outside the womb, whether or not the child was ever born alive.

Twenty years later, in Thibert v. Milka, 419 Mass. 693 (1995), the court declined to extend the rule. A fetus that was not viable at the time of injury and death is not a “person” under the statute, and no wrongful death action lies for its loss. The court left that question to the legislature, which has not changed the statute.

The result is a two-part rule:

  • If the child was viable when injured and died, whether before or after birth, the family has a wrongful death claim under M.G.L. c. 229, § 2.
  • If the child was not viable, there is no wrongful death claim for the child, but the mother has her own claims, described below.

What viability means and how it is proved

Viability is the point at which the fetus is capable of surviving outside the womb, with or without medical support. It is a medical question answered by gestational age, weight, and development, and it is proved by the prenatal records, ultrasound measurements, and expert obstetric and neonatal testimony. Modern neonatal care has moved the threshold earlier than it was in 1975, and the question in a borderline case is contested. A child injured in the second trimester presents a harder question than one injured at thirty-six weeks.

A child born alive who dies from prenatal injuries is a person regardless of gestational age at injury, and the wrongful death claim lies.

The wrongful death claim for a viable child

The claim is brought by a personal representative appointed for the child’s estate, on behalf of the beneficiaries under M.G.L. c. 229, § 1. For a child who leaves no spouse or children, the beneficiaries are the next of kin: the parents, equally. Our page on wrongful death beneficiaries explains the categories.

Damages under § 2 are the fair monetary value of the child to the parents, including the loss of the child’s reasonably expected society, companionship, and comfort, and funeral and burial expenses. Massachusetts juries have recognized that the loss of a child’s entire life is a profound loss, and the defense argument that the parents never knew the child is answered by the evidence of the pregnancy, the preparations, and the family’s experience. Punitive damages are available for gross negligence or reckless conduct, as in a drunk driving case. Our page on the wrongful death of a child covers the damages in detail.

A conscious suffering claim under § 6 is rarely available for a stillborn child, because consciousness cannot be shown. For a child born alive who survived for a period, it is.

The mother’s own claims

Whether or not the child was viable, the mother was injured, and she has her own claims that do not depend on the viability rule:

  • Personal injury. Her physical injuries from the crash, fall, or assault, the medical treatment, including delivery of the stillborn child, and her lost earnings.
  • Emotional distress. The loss of the pregnancy is a component of the mother’s own damages for her injury. Where the mother was physically injured, her emotional distress from the loss of the child is recoverable as part of that claim. Where she was not physically injured but witnessed the event, bystander principles may apply. Our page on bystander emotional distress explains the requirements.
  • Medical malpractice. In a birth injury or prenatal care case, the mother is the physician’s patient and has her own malpractice claim for negligent care, including the delivery, in addition to the child’s wrongful death claim if the child was viable.

The father’s claims are narrower. He may have a loss of consortium claim arising from the mother’s injuries, and he is a beneficiary of the child’s wrongful death claim if the child was viable.

Common case types

Motor vehicle crashes

Placental abruption from the force of a collision is the most common mechanism of fetal death in trauma, and it can occur in moderate-speed crashes with proper seat belt use. The claim is against the at-fault driver and is handled like any motor vehicle wrongful death case, with the added question of viability. Our page on car crash wrongful death covers the process.

Obstetric negligence

Failure to respond to non-reassuring fetal monitoring, delayed cesarean delivery, mismanaged shoulder dystocia, undiagnosed preeclampsia, failure to act on decreased fetal movement, and medication errors. These are medical malpractice cases subject to the tribunal under M.G.L. c. 231, § 60B, the fee schedule, and the charitable cap on the hospital. The child at term is viable, and the wrongful death claim lies alongside the mother’s malpractice claim. Our page on birth injury and infant death addresses these cases.

Assault

Where the mother is assaulted and the child dies, the civil claim proceeds against the assailant regardless of the criminal case. Collectability is the usual limitation. Our page on wrongful death and criminal cases explains the interaction.

Falls and premises

A fall on dangerous property during pregnancy that causes abruption or premature labor is a premises case with the same viability analysis.

Deadlines

The wrongful death claim must be filed within three years of the child’s death. The mother’s personal injury claim must be filed within three years of the injury. A medical malpractice claim on behalf of a child has its own rules, and the minor’s tolling provisions do not apply to a child who did not survive. Our page on the statute of limitations covers the periods.

Questions families ask

Can you sue for the wrongful death of an unborn child in Massachusetts?

Yes, if the child was viable when injured. Mone v. Greyhound Lines, 368 Mass. 354 (1975), holds that a viable fetus is a person under the wrongful death statute. Under Thibert v. Milka, 419 Mass. 693 (1995), there is no wrongful death claim for a non-viable fetus, but the mother has her own claims.

Is a miscarriage at ten weeks caused by a car crash a wrongful death?

Not under the statute, because the child was not viable. The mother’s own injury claim includes the loss of the pregnancy as an element of her damages.

Who are the beneficiaries when a stillborn child’s death is a wrongful death?

The parents, as next of kin, equally.

Does a stillbirth caused by medical negligence require the malpractice tribunal?

Yes. The claim against the obstetrician and hospital is a malpractice claim subject to M.G.L. c. 231, § 60B and the other malpractice statutes.

Does the father have a claim?

He is a beneficiary of the child’s wrongful death claim if the child was viable, and he may have a loss of consortium claim arising from the mother’s injuries.

If you lost a pregnancy or a newborn because of someone’s negligence, the questions of viability and of the mother’s own claims need to be answered from the records. Call us and we will do that with you. There is no fee unless we recover for you. Call 617-415-2100.

Related guides

Wrongful death of a child · Birth injury and infant death · Beneficiaries · Bystander emotional distress · Complete guide

Attorney Christopher Murphy, Esq.

Attorney at Scalli Murphy Law, P.C., practicing law in Massachusetts since 1999 with a focus on serious injury and wrongful death cases. This overview is general information and not legal advice.

Talk with a Massachusetts wrongful death lawyer

Free, private, and no obligation.

Call 617-415-2100

📞  Free Consultation — 617-415-2100 📞  Free Consultation — 617-415-2100