Choosing a wrongful death lawyer is a decision most families make once, under the worst conditions, with no way to compare the result against what another lawyer would have achieved. The advertising does not help. Every firm says it is aggressive, compassionate, and experienced. This page is a practical guide to what actually distinguishes lawyers who handle Massachusetts wrongful death cases well, the questions to ask in a first meeting, the answers that should concern you, and the parts of the decision that matter less than people think. We handle these cases ourselves, so read it with that in mind; the test of the advice is whether it would help you evaluate us as critically as anyone else.
What a wrongful death case demands of a lawyer
A wrongful death case in Massachusetts is not a large personal injury case. It has its own statute, M.G.L. c. 229, § 2, its own party structure, its own damages categories, and its own procedural steps. The lawyer must be able to:
- Get a personal representative appointed in the Probate and Family Court, because no suit can be filed without one.
- Investigate liability quickly, with preservation demands, scene work, and expert involvement before evidence disappears.
- Prove damages that are not on any bill: the value of a parent’s guidance, a spouse’s companionship, a child’s future.
- Handle the survival action under M.G.L. c. 228, § 1 for the decedent’s own suffering alongside the wrongful death claim.
- Handle the special rules for the case type: the medical malpractice tribunal under M.G.L. c. 231, § 60B, presentment under the Tort Claims Act for public defendants, workers’ compensation exclusivity and liens, nursing home arbitration clauses.
- Identify every source of insurance, since a verdict is only worth what can be collected.
- Manage the settlement approval and allocation process in the Probate Court, including the protection of minor beneficiaries.
- Try the case to a jury if the insurer will not pay what the loss is worth.
A lawyer who is excellent at settling soft-tissue car cases may have done none of these things. Ask directly.
Questions to ask in the first meeting
About experience
- How many wrongful death cases have you personally handled to resolution in Massachusetts, as opposed to the firm as a whole?
- How many of those involved my case type (medical negligence, nursing home, truck crash, workplace, product)?
- When did you last try a case to a jury verdict? What was it?
- Have you handled a case against this defendant or this insurer before?
About who does the work
- Who will be the lawyer responsible for my case day to day? Will I meet them today?
- Will the case be referred to another firm? If so, which one, and who supervises?
- How will I be kept informed, and how quickly are calls returned?
Large advertising firms frequently refer cases out or assign them to junior lawyers with heavy caseloads. That is not always bad, but you are entitled to know before you sign, and the referral arrangement must be disclosed to you in writing under the Massachusetts rules of professional conduct.
About the plan
- Based on what I have told you, what are the strengths and weaknesses of the case?
- What will you do in the first thirty days?
- Which experts will the case need, and have you worked with them before?
- What is the likely timeline, and what are the deadlines I should know about?
About money
- What is the contingent fee percentage, and does it change if the case goes to trial or appeal?
- Are case costs deducted before or after the fee is calculated?
- Who pays the costs if there is no recovery?
- If this is a medical case, how will the fee cap under M.G.L. c. 231, § 60I be applied?
- How will liens from health insurers, MassHealth, Medicare, or a workers’ compensation insurer be handled and negotiated?
The fee agreement must be in writing, signed by you, and clear on each of these points. Our page on what a wrongful death lawyer costs explains the structure.
Answers that should concern you
- A dollar figure or a promise in the first meeting. No one can value a wrongful death case before reviewing the records. A number offered to win your signature is a sales technique. Our page on whether there is an average settlement explains why.
- Pressure to sign today. Deadlines are real, but a day or two to consider the decision will not change the outcome, and a lawyer who says otherwise is managing you rather than advising you.
- Vagueness about who will handle the case. If you cannot get a name, assume the answer is someone you have not met.
- No trial experience. Insurers know which lawyers will try cases and which will not, and they price claims accordingly. A lawyer who has never tried a case is negotiating from weakness no matter how the demand letter reads.
- Dismissiveness about bad facts. If your family member was partly at fault, had a serious pre-existing condition, or waited to seek care, a good lawyer will want to know all of it and will tell you how it affects the case. A lawyer who waves it away has not thought about how the defense will use it.
- Contact you did not invite. Massachusetts rules prohibit lawyers from soliciting clients in person or by live telephone contact when the lawyer’s motive is financial gain. A lawyer or “investigator” who shows up at your door or calls you after a death is breaking those rules, and that tells you something about the firm.
Things that matter less than you might think
Office location. A wrongful death case is built from records, experts, and courtroom work. The lawyer will meet you where you are, and the case will be filed in the county with venue regardless of where the office is. A firm an hour away with real wrongful death experience is a better choice than a nearby firm without it. Our areas we serve page lists the counties and cities we regularly handle cases in.
Firm size. Large firms have resources. Small firms have attention. Either can handle a wrongful death case well. What matters is the specific lawyer’s experience and the firm’s willingness to advance the costs the case requires, which in a medical or product case can be substantial.
Awards and ratings. Many legal awards are purchased or are based on peer nominations within a small network. Some ratings services are meaningful; many are marketing. Treat them as a starting point for questions, not as a credential.
Advertising volume. The firm whose billboard you see is the firm with the largest advertising budget. That budget is paid from fees. It says nothing about results.
How to check what a lawyer tells you
- Board of Bar Overseers. The Massachusetts Board of Bar Overseers maintains a public attorney lookup showing whether a lawyer is in good standing and whether public discipline has been imposed. Check every lawyer you are considering.
- Court records. Massachusetts trial court dockets are searchable online. A lawyer who claims trial experience should appear as counsel of record in cases that went to verdict.
- Published decisions. Appellate decisions name the lawyers who argued them. A lawyer who has handled significant wrongful death cases is likely to appear in some.
- References. Ask for a former client in a wrongful death case who is willing to speak with you. Firms that have done the work can usually arrange it.
When to make the decision
Sooner than feels comfortable. Evidence disappears in the weeks after a death, and some deadlines are short: presentment to a public entity under M.G.L. c. 258 must be made within a limited window, and insurance claims and appeals carry contractual deadlines. The statute of limitations for the wrongful death claim itself is generally three years, but under Fabiano v. Philip Morris USA Inc. (SJC-13282, 2023) it may be shorter where the decedent’s own claim was already running. A family does not have to decide on a lawyer the week of the funeral, but it should not let months pass. Our page on the statute of limitations covers the deadlines, and our page on what to do after a wrongful death covers the first steps.
Changing lawyers
A family that has already hired a lawyer and is dissatisfied can change. The original lawyer is entitled to be paid for the value of work done, usually out of the eventual fee rather than from the family, and the new lawyer handles the transition. Reasons families change include unreturned calls, discovering the case was referred out without disclosure, pressure to accept a low settlement, and learning that the lawyer has no intention of trying the case. Switching late in a case is disruptive; switching early is routine.
Questions families ask
Should I hire a wrongful death lawyer or a personal injury lawyer?
Wrongful death is a specialized area within personal injury practice. The question is not the label but whether the specific lawyer has handled Massachusetts wrongful death cases to resolution, understands the probate and allocation process, and has tried cases.
Does it matter whether the lawyer is in my county?
Very little. The case will be filed where venue is proper, and the work is done through records and experts. Experience with wrongful death cases matters far more than geography.
What does a wrongful death lawyer cost?
Nothing up front. These cases are handled on a contingency fee, with the fee paid from the recovery and only if there is one. Medical negligence cases are subject to a statutory cap on the percentage. The agreement must be in writing.
Can I interview more than one lawyer?
Yes, and you should if you have any doubt. A consultation does not obligate you. Be aware that the deadlines keep running while you decide.
What if a lawyer contacted me first?
Direct in-person or live telephone solicitation of a grieving family for the lawyer’s financial gain violates the Massachusetts rules of professional conduct. You are under no obligation to that lawyer, and the conduct is a reason to look elsewhere.
If you are deciding whom to trust with your family’s case, call us and ask every question on this page. We will answer them directly. There is no fee unless we recover for you. Call 617-415-2100.
Related guides
What a lawyer costs · Chances of winning · The claim process · About Attorney Murphy · Complete guide