Heart attacks and strokes are the two conditions emergency departments most often miss, and the two in which a missed diagnosis most often kills. Both are time-critical: the treatments that save heart muscle and brain tissue work only within hours. A patient sent home from a Massachusetts emergency department with a diagnosis of anxiety, indigestion, a migraine, or vertigo, who dies that night or returns the next day beyond help, is the paradigm of a wrongful death caused by failure to diagnose. This page explains how these cases are proved in Massachusetts, the loss of chance doctrine that makes them viable even when survival was uncertain, and the rules that govern them.
How heart attacks are missed
The classic presentation of crushing chest pain radiating to the left arm is not the common one. Women, diabetics, and older patients often present with shortness of breath, nausea, fatigue, jaw or back pain, or a sense that something is wrong. The errors that recur in these cases:
- Attributing symptoms to acid reflux, musculoskeletal pain, or anxiety without ruling out a cardiac cause.
- A single electrocardiogram read as normal, with no repeat and no serial troponin testing, when the standard of care calls for both.
- Troponin drawn too early, before it rises, and not repeated.
- An abnormal ECG misread by the emergency physician, or a computer interpretation accepted without physician review.
- Discharge without a cardiology consult or stress testing in a patient with risk factors.
- Failure to act on a critical troponin result that came back after the patient left.
- In a primary care setting, a patient with new exertional symptoms sent home without an urgent workup.
How strokes are missed
Stroke treatment is governed by the clock. Clot-dissolving medication and clot-retrieval procedures are effective only within a narrow window from symptom onset, and every delay reduces the chance of recovery. The errors:
- Dizziness, headache, nausea, or confusion attributed to vertigo, migraine, intoxication, or a psychiatric cause, particularly in younger patients and women.
- Posterior circulation strokes, which affect balance and vision rather than producing one-sided weakness, dismissed as inner ear problems.
- A CT scan read as negative and treated as ruling out stroke, when early ischemic stroke is often invisible on CT and the standard calls for further evaluation.
- Transient symptoms that resolved, a transient ischemic attack, treated as nothing, when it is a warning of imminent stroke requiring urgent workup.
- Delay in neurology consultation or transfer to a stroke center.
- Failure to manage anticoagulation in atrial fibrillation patients, or stopping it without a plan.
Proving the case
A Massachusetts medical malpractice death case requires proof that the provider departed from the standard of care of the average qualified practitioner in the specialty, and that the departure caused the death. Both elements require expert testimony, and the case cannot be filed without an expert’s support because of the tribunal described below. The evidence:
- The emergency department record, including triage notes, vital signs, the physician’s documented differential diagnosis, orders, results, and discharge instructions. The timestamps matter: when the patient arrived, when the ECG was done, when results posted, when the patient left.
- The ECG tracings and imaging themselves, not just the reports, reviewed by the plaintiff’s experts.
- The return visit or autopsy, establishing what the condition actually was and when it began.
- Expert testimony from emergency medicine, cardiology or neurology, and sometimes radiology, on what should have been done and what would have followed.
Loss of chance: the doctrine that makes these cases possible
The defense in every missed heart attack or stroke case is that the patient might have died even with perfect care. For decades that argument defeated cases where the chance of survival was below fifty percent. In Matsuyama v. Birnbaum, 452 Mass. 1 (2008), the Supreme Judicial Court recognized loss of chance as a basis for recovery in medical malpractice wrongful death cases. A plaintiff who proves that negligence destroyed a substantial chance of survival recovers damages proportioned to the chance lost. If timely treatment would have given the patient a forty percent chance of survival and the negligence reduced it to nearly nothing, the family recovers forty percent of the full wrongful death damages. The doctrine fits heart attack and stroke cases precisely, because the medical literature quantifies survival and recovery by time to treatment. Our page on loss of chance explains the doctrine in detail.
The Massachusetts rules that apply
- The tribunal. Under M.G.L. c. 231, § 60B, the case goes before a judge, a physician, and a lawyer, who decide whether the offer of proof raises a legitimate question of liability. A plaintiff who does not pass must post a $6,000 bond per defendant to continue.
- Defendants and caps. The emergency physician is often employed by a contracted staffing group rather than the hospital. The hospital, if a nonprofit charity, is capped at $100,000 for malpractice under M.G.L. c. 231, § 85K; the physician and a for-profit group are not. Our page on hospital wrongful death settlements explains how this affects value.
- Fees. M.G.L. c. 231, § 60I sets the sliding contingent fee scale for malpractice cases.
- Deadlines. Generally three years from death, subject to the discovery rule and the Fabiano rule that a wrongful death claim is barred where the decedent’s own claim was already time-barred. In a missed diagnosis case where the patient survived for a time after the error, the decedent’s own clock may have started at the misdiagnosis. Our page on the statute of limitations covers the rules.
Damages
The family recovers under M.G.L. c. 229, § 2 for the loss of the decedent’s income, services, companionship, and guidance, and funeral expenses. Heart attack and stroke victims are often working adults with dependents, which makes the economic component substantial. The decedent’s conscious suffering between the missed diagnosis and death, often a second event at home or a return to the hospital in extremis, is recovered under § 6. Our page on wrongful death damages explains the categories. Where a stroke patient survived with catastrophic disability for a period before death, the survival claim includes that period.
Where these cases arise
Community hospital emergency departments with limited overnight specialist coverage, urgent care centers that lack the capacity to evaluate cardiac or neurological emergencies but attempt it, telehealth encounters, and primary care offices. Transfers between facilities, where delay occurs in the handoff, are a recurring pattern in stroke cases in regions distant from a comprehensive stroke center.
Questions families ask
Can you sue for a missed heart attack in Massachusetts?
Yes, if an expert concludes the emergency physician or other provider departed from the standard of care and the departure caused the death or the loss of a substantial chance of survival. The case goes through the medical malpractice tribunal before proceeding.
What if the doctors say he would have died anyway?
Under Matsuyama v. Birnbaum, the family can recover for the loss of a substantial chance of survival even if that chance was below fifty percent, with damages proportioned to the chance lost.
The CT scan was negative. Does that end a stroke case?
No. Early ischemic stroke is often not visible on CT. Whether the standard of care required further evaluation given the symptoms is the question, and it is answered by expert testimony.
How long do we have?
Generally three years from death, but the decedent’s own claim may have started running at the misdiagnosis, and under Fabiano that can shorten the family’s deadline. Consult counsel promptly.
What will it cost to find out whether there is a case?
Nothing. We obtain the records and have them reviewed. Fees in malpractice cases are contingent and set by statute.
If a family member was sent home from a Massachusetts emergency department or doctor’s office and died of a heart attack or stroke shortly afterward, the records will show what was done and what was not. Call us and we will get them reviewed. There is no fee unless we recover for you. Call 617-415-2100.
Related guides
Failure to diagnose · Loss of chance · Medical malpractice deaths · Hospital settlements · Complete guide