A Massachusetts wrongful death resource · Danvers, MA · Serving families since 1994 Speak with an attorney: 617-415-2100

Conscious Pain and Suffering in a Massachusetts Wrongful Death Case

Massachusetts wrongful death cases usually contain two claims, and families often hear only about one. The first is the beneficiaries’ claim for what they lost. The second is the decedent’s own claim for what he or she experienced between the injury and death: the fear, the pain, the awareness of dying. The law calls it conscious pain and suffering, and it is recovered under M.G.L. c. 229, § 6. In some cases it is a small part of the recovery. In others, a fall that led to weeks in intensive care, a fire, a drowning, a delayed diagnosis, it is the largest component. This page explains what the claim is, how it is proved, what the defense argues, and why the money it produces is treated differently from everything else in the case.

The statute

M.G.L. c. 229, § 6 provides that in any wrongful death action under § 2, “damages may be recovered for conscious suffering resulting from the same injury, but any sum so recovered shall be held and disposed of by the executors or administrators as assets of the estate of the deceased.” Three points follow from the text. The claim is brought in the same lawsuit as the wrongful death claim. It compensates suffering the decedent consciously experienced. And the recovery belongs to the estate, not to the wrongful death beneficiaries.

What “conscious” requires

The word is the center of the claim. The decedent must have been aware, for some period, of pain, fear, or distress. Death that is instantaneous, or that follows immediately on loss of consciousness, supports no conscious suffering recovery no matter how terrible the event. The defense in nearly every case argues that the decedent lost consciousness at impact or never knew what was happening. The plaintiff’s task is to prove awareness, and the period of awareness can be short. Courts have allowed recovery for seconds of terror before a collision, for the minutes of a drowning, and for the hours between a fall and death.

Consciousness is not the same as the ability to speak. A patient who is intubated, sedated but rousable, or who responds to pain or to a family member’s voice may be conscious for this purpose. Medical records that document responses to stimuli, Glasgow Coma Scale scores, requests for pain medication, and nursing notes describing agitation or grimacing are evidence of awareness.

How the claim is proved

Because the decedent cannot testify, the proof is assembled from everyone and everything around the death:

  • Medical records. Emergency medical service run sheets record responsiveness at the scene. Emergency department and intensive care notes record consciousness, pain scores, sedation levels, and the decedent’s own statements. Pain medication orders are themselves evidence that pain was present and recognized.
  • The medical examiner. Autopsy findings can establish that the decedent was alive and breathing for a period after the injury: soot in the airway in a fire, water in the lungs in a drowning, hemorrhage patterns that require circulation. The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner’s report is often decisive on the sequence.
  • Witnesses. First responders, bystanders, other patients, and family members who were present can describe what the decedent said and did. Statements like “help me,” “I can’t breathe,” or calling a family member’s name are powerful evidence.
  • Physical evidence. Skid marks and event data recorder downloads show that a driver perceived the hazard and reacted before impact. Defensive injuries show awareness in an assault. The position of a body can show an attempt to escape.
  • Expert testimony. A physician can explain what a given injury feels like, how long consciousness would persist with that injury, and what the records reveal. In a case with a disputed period of awareness, the expert’s reconstruction of the timeline is the core of the claim.

Duration matters, but it is not everything

The jury considers how long the suffering lasted and how intense it was. A long hospitalization with repeated surgeries, infections, and awareness of a worsening prognosis produces a large claim. But a short period of extreme terror also has real value, and juries recognize it. The pre-impact fright of a passenger who sees the collision coming, or the awareness of a person trapped in a burning building, is compensable even when death follows within a minute. The claim should never be abandoned simply because death was quick, until the evidence of awareness has actually been examined.

Cases where the claim is often large

  • Nursing home neglect. Pressure injuries, untreated infections, dehydration, and falls produce weeks or months of documented suffering before death. Our page on bedsore deaths explains the proof.
  • Delayed diagnosis. A patient who dies of a cancer or a condition that should have been caught earlier often endures a long decline, with the added suffering of knowing it was avoidable. Our page on failure to diagnose addresses these cases.
  • Burns and fires. Burn injuries are among the most painful known, and survival for days in a burn unit is common before death. Our page on burn and fire deaths covers them.
  • Drowning. Medical evidence establishes a period of struggle and awareness in most drownings.
  • Sepsis. The progression from infection to septic shock is prolonged and documented. Our page on sepsis deaths explains the timeline.
  • Trauma with hospitalization. A crash victim who survives for days in intensive care, undergoes surgery, and dies of complications has a substantial claim regardless of the family’s wrongful death losses.

Why the recovery is treated differently

The wrongful death recovery under § 2 goes to the statutory beneficiaries and is not an estate asset. The conscious suffering recovery under § 6 is an estate asset. The consequences:

  • It passes under the decedent’s will or, with no will, by intestacy. The recipients may differ from the wrongful death beneficiaries. A partner named in a will, or a charity, can receive conscious suffering damages while receiving nothing under § 2.
  • It is subject to the estate’s debts, including medical bills from the final illness and MassHealth estate recovery.
  • It is subject to any applicable estate tax and is counted in the probate estate.

Because of this, the allocation of a settlement between the wrongful death claim and the conscious suffering claim is one of the most consequential decisions in the case. The insurer pays one sum; how it is divided determines who receives it and what creditors can reach. The allocation is presented to the Probate and Family Court for approval, and it must be supported by the evidence rather than chosen for convenience. Our page on wrongful death versus survival claims explains the two claims side by side, and our page on who gets the money explains the allocation hearing.

The defense playbook

Defendants attack conscious suffering claims in predictable ways: arguing instantaneous death or immediate unconsciousness; characterizing medical records of sedation as proof of no awareness; disputing the expert’s timeline; and, where the decedent was elderly or ill, arguing that the suffering was caused by the underlying condition rather than the negligence. Each has an answer in the evidence, and a lawyer who has tried these cases knows where to find it. The claim should be developed from the first week, when first responders’ memories are fresh and records can be preserved.

Questions families ask

What is conscious pain and suffering in a wrongful death case?

It is the decedent’s own claim for the physical pain and mental distress he or she consciously experienced between the injury and death, recovered under M.G.L. c. 229, § 6 in the same action as the wrongful death claim.

Is there a conscious suffering claim if death was instant?

If the decedent had no awareness at all, no. But the question is factual, and evidence of even a few seconds of awareness, such as a reaction before impact, supports the claim. It should be investigated before it is written off.

Who receives conscious pain and suffering damages?

The decedent’s estate. The money passes under the will or by intestacy, after estate debts, rather than to the wrongful death beneficiaries directly.

How is conscious suffering proved when the person cannot testify?

Through medical and EMS records, the medical examiner’s findings, witnesses who were present, physical evidence, and expert testimony reconstructing the timeline of awareness.

Is the conscious suffering claim subject to the medical malpractice damages cap?

M.G.L. c. 231, § 60H caps general damages in malpractice actions but by its terms excludes actions brought under M.G.L. c. 229, § 2. How the cap applies to the conscious suffering component of a wrongful death action is a question to raise with counsel in any medical case.

If your family member survived for any period after the injury that caused death, there is a second claim in the case, and it should be developed with the same care as the first. Call us for a direct assessment. There is no fee unless we recover for you. Call 617-415-2100.

Related guides

Survival actions · Wrongful death damages · Who gets the money · How to prove wrongful death · Complete guide

Attorney Christopher Murphy, Esq.

Attorney at Scalli Murphy Law, P.C., practicing law in Massachusetts since 1999 with a focus on serious injury and wrongful death cases. This overview is general information and not legal advice.

Talk with a Massachusetts wrongful death lawyer

Free, private, and no obligation.

Call 617-415-2100

📞  Free Consultation — 617-415-2100 📞  Free Consultation — 617-415-2100