Most descriptions of the wrongful death process stop at the courthouse door: hire a lawyer, investigate, send a demand, file suit. Families who are already in a lawsuit, or about to be, want to know what happens after that. This page walks through the steps in a Massachusetts wrongful death lawsuit in order, from the appointment that makes filing possible through the complaint, the tracking order, discovery, expert work, motions, mediation, trial, and the court approval that ends the case. It is written for the Superior Court, where serious wrongful death cases are filed, and it notes where medical, governmental, and nursing home cases take a different path.
Step 1: Appointment of the personal representative
Nothing can be filed until the Probate and Family Court appoints a personal representative of the decedent’s estate. The Massachusetts wrongful death statute, M.G.L. c. 229, § 2, gives the right to sue to that person alone. Appointment comes through informal probate, which is quick when there is no dispute, or formal probate when there is a contest or a complication. The lawyer’s investigation runs in parallel with the appointment, but the three-year limitation period does not pause for probate, so this step should start immediately. See the personal representative’s role.
Step 2: Pre-suit investigation and the decision to file
Before filing, the lawyer gathers the records, sends preservation demands, interviews witnesses, retains experts where the case type requires them, and identifies every potential defendant and every insurance policy. In many cases a demand is sent to the insurer and settlement is explored. Some cases settle at this stage. Many do not, either because the insurer disputes liability, because it values the case too low, or because the limitation period is approaching and suit must be filed to preserve the claim. Our page on the wrongful death claim process covers this pre-suit phase in detail; this page picks up where it leaves off.
Two case types have a required pre-suit step. A claim against a city, town, or state agency must be presented in writing to the proper executive officer under M.G.L. c. 258 within the statutory window before suit may be filed. A medical negligence claim does not require pre-suit notice, but the expert support the tribunal will demand must be in hand before the complaint is drafted.
Step 3: The complaint
The lawsuit begins with a complaint filed in the Superior Court for a county with proper venue, usually where a party resides or where the death occurred. The complaint names the personal representative as plaintiff, identifies the defendants, states the facts, and sets out the counts: wrongful death under c. 229, § 2, the survival action under M.G.L. c. 228, § 1 for the decedent’s conscious suffering, and any additional counts the facts support, such as gross negligence for punitive damages, breach of warranty against a product manufacturer, or a claim under the dram shop statute. A civil action cover sheet accompanies the complaint and drives the tracking designation discussed below. The complaint is filed electronically and a filing fee is paid, which is advanced by the firm as a case cost.
Step 4: Service and the defendants’ response
Each defendant must be formally served with the summons and complaint, typically by a sheriff or constable, within the time the rules allow. Once served, a defendant has a set period to file an answer, which admits or denies each allegation and raises affirmative defenses such as comparative negligence, statute of limitations, or the charitable cap. Some defendants respond instead with a motion to dismiss, arguing that the complaint is legally insufficient. Defendants may also bring in additional parties they contend share responsibility, and may file cross-claims against one another. The pleadings stage is where the lines of the case are drawn.
Step 5: The tracking order
Shortly after filing, the Superior Court issues a tracking order under its time standards, Standing Order 1-88. The order assigns the case to a track based on the case type stated on the cover sheet and sets deadlines for each stage: service, responsive pleadings, completion of discovery, filing of dispositive motions, the final pretrial conference, and trial readiness. Tort cases, including wrongful death, are generally assigned to the average track, with a longer schedule than fast-track matters. The tracking order is the backbone of the case’s calendar. Deadlines can be extended by motion for good cause, and in complex cases frequently are, but they are not optional, and a party that ignores them risks sanctions or dismissal.
Step 6: The medical malpractice tribunal (medical cases only)
If any defendant is a provider of health care, the case is referred to a tribunal under M.G.L. c. 231, § 60B. A single justice, a physician, and an attorney review the plaintiff’s offer of proof, which consists of the medical records and an expert’s opinion, and determine whether the evidence raises a legitimate question of liability appropriate for judicial inquiry. A finding for the plaintiff allows the case to proceed normally. A finding for the defendant requires the plaintiff to post a bond to continue. The tribunal generally sits within months of filing and is the first major checkpoint in a medical death case. See wrongful death vs. medical malpractice.
Step 7: Written discovery
Discovery is the formal exchange of information, and it is where most of the case is built. Written discovery includes interrogatories, which are written questions answered under oath; requests for production of documents, which in a wrongful death case can run to thousands of pages of medical, employment, maintenance, personnel, and insurance records; and requests for admission. The plaintiff learns the defendant’s version of events and obtains the defendant’s internal records. The defendant learns about the decedent’s health, earnings, and family relationships, which bear on damages. Subpoenas go to third parties: employers, treating providers, phone carriers, government agencies. Disputes over what must be produced are resolved by motion.
Step 8: Depositions
Depositions are sworn testimony taken outside court, recorded by a stenographer and often by video. In a wrongful death case the plaintiff’s lawyer deposes the defendant, the defendant’s employees, eyewitnesses, investigating officers, and treating providers. The defense deposes the personal representative, the beneficiaries, and the people who can speak to the decedent’s life, work, and relationships. Depositions lock in testimony, reveal the strength of each side’s witnesses, and frequently move the parties toward settlement. Family members are prepared carefully for their depositions; the defense will probe the decedent’s conduct, health, and the family’s relationships, and candid, composed testimony is the best answer.
Step 9: Expert disclosure and expert discovery
Each side discloses the experts it intends to call and the substance of their opinions. In a wrongful death case the plaintiff’s experts may include a liability expert in the relevant field (a physician, an engineer, a crash reconstructionist, a long-term care specialist), a forensic economist to calculate lost earnings and the value of lost services, and sometimes a vocational or life-care specialist. The defense retains its own. Experts may be deposed. The expert phase is expensive and is advanced by the firm as a case cost; it is also where many cases are won or lost, because the credibility of the competing experts is what the jury will weigh.
Step 10: Motions
Throughout discovery and at its close, the parties file motions. Discovery motions compel production or protect against overreach. Motions for summary judgment argue that the undisputed facts entitle a party to judgment on some or all claims without trial; defendants commonly move for summary judgment on punitive damages, on particular defendants, or on causation. Motions in limine, filed before trial, ask the judge to admit or exclude specific evidence. In the Superior Court, motions are served on the opposing party under Rule 9A and filed as a package with the opposition, and are decided on the papers or after a hearing.
Step 11: Mediation and settlement
Most wrongful death cases that survive the motion stage settle before trial, and many settle at mediation, a confidential session with a neutral mediator, often a retired judge, who works with both sides toward a number. Mediation can happen at any point but is most productive after depositions and expert disclosures, when each side can evaluate the other’s case. A settlement is documented in a written agreement and, in a wrongful death case, must be approved by the Probate and Family Court, which reviews the allocation among the beneficiaries and the fee. See mediation and settlement of wrongful death cases.
Step 12: Final pretrial conference and trial
If the case does not settle, the court holds a final pretrial conference, at which the parties submit a memorandum identifying witnesses, exhibits, and disputed legal issues, and a trial date is set. A wrongful death trial in the Superior Court is a jury trial unless the parties waive it. It proceeds through jury selection, opening statements, the plaintiff’s evidence, the defendants’ evidence, closing arguments, jury instructions, and deliberation. The jury decides liability, apportions fault among the parties including the decedent, and determines damages in each statutory category. A wrongful death trial typically lasts one to two weeks; complex medical or product cases can run longer. See what to expect at a wrongful death trial.
Step 13: Post-trial motions and appeal
After a verdict, the losing party may move for judgment notwithstanding the verdict, for a new trial, or for remittitur (a reduction of the damages). Either side may appeal to the Appeals Court, and in significant cases the Supreme Judicial Court may take the case directly. An appeal adds a year or more. Judgments accrue interest from the date the complaint was filed, which is a meaningful consideration for defendants deciding whether to appeal.
Step 14: Approval, liens, and distribution
Whether by settlement or judgment, the recovery passes through the Probate and Family Court for approval of the allocation among the beneficiaries. Liens held by health insurers, MassHealth, Medicare, or a workers’ compensation insurer are resolved, usually with negotiation. The fee and costs are deducted under the written agreement, and the net is distributed under the approved plan. Shares belonging to minors are placed under court supervision. See who receives the money and court approval where a minor is a beneficiary.
How long the steps take
From filing to resolution, a Massachusetts wrongful death case in the Superior Court commonly takes two to three years, longer if it goes to trial and is appealed. Medical cases take longer than motor vehicle cases because of the tribunal and the expert work. Cases against public entities are slowed by the presentment process. Cases with multiple defendants or disputed insurance coverage take longer than cases with one defendant and a clear policy. Our page on how long a wrongful death lawsuit takes discusses the variables.
What the family does during the lawsuit
Less than people fear, and more than nothing. The personal representative signs discovery responses, sits for a deposition, attends mediation, and testifies at trial if there is one. Beneficiaries may be deposed and may testify. The family provides the documents and the memories that prove the human loss: photographs, letters, financial records, the account of who the decedent was. Between those events, the lawyer carries the case, and the family’s role is to stay informed and to make the decisions that are theirs: whether to accept a settlement, and whether to go to trial.
Questions families ask
What is the first step in a wrongful death lawsuit in Massachusetts?
Appointment of a personal representative by the Probate and Family Court. Without it, no complaint can be filed. The investigation can begin while the appointment is pending.
Where is a wrongful death lawsuit filed?
Serious cases are filed in the Superior Court for a county with proper venue. Claims against public entities and medical providers are filed in the same court but follow additional procedures.
Will I have to testify?
The personal representative will almost certainly be deposed and will testify if the case goes to trial. Beneficiaries may be deposed and may testify about their relationship with the decedent. You will be prepared for each step.
Can the case settle at any point?
Yes. Settlement can occur before suit, during discovery, at mediation, on the eve of trial, during trial, or after a verdict while an appeal is pending. Every settlement in a wrongful death case must be approved by the Probate and Family Court.
What is a tracking order?
A schedule issued by the Superior Court under Standing Order 1-88 that sets the deadlines for each stage of the case, from service through trial readiness. It can be amended by motion for good cause.
If your family is considering a wrongful death lawsuit, or is already in one and wants a clearer picture of what comes next, call us. We will walk you through each step. There is no fee unless we recover for you. Call 617-415-2100.
Related guides
The claim process before suit · How long it takes · What to expect at trial · Mediation and settlement · Complete guide
Talk with a Massachusetts wrongful death trial lawyer
Free, private, and no obligation.